One Mobile App success does not a summer make

There are a number of people whose blogs I always read, and when it comes to incisive comment on Planet Mobile one of those is Dean Bubley who writes Disruptive Wireless. I thought his recent piece on Mobile Apps was particularly useful when I read a story about an app on android selling $13,000 pm

Numbers

- About 70,000 downloads of the free version.
- 6,590 downloads of the paid version
- Price of the app was raised from $1.99 to $3.99
- The app steadily climbed the charts, briefly reaching a peak of #4 in the Travel category for paid apps.

Good luck to them, but putting one's business hat on I asked "is this a business model" - and then recalled Dean's post:

Wandering around Barcelona last week, I started feeling a deep unease at the current level of hysteria around mobile apps. It is was compounded this week by seeing a T-Mobile advert on the London Underground which didn't show a phone, but just said "Would you like a free phone with apps for just £20 a month?" [meaning "We'll sell you a cheap Android instead of an iPhone, but don't dare mention it or show it"]. Apple is bombarding the world with "apps, apps, apps" advertising as well.

That was what was on my mind too - as Dean says, this may not be sustainable:

But maybe it's just a fashion? After all, do you really want any form of ongoing "relationship" with a handset manufacturer? Will the mass market really want to keep adding new stuff to their device?

The first 100-200m owners of PCs bought and installed lots of applications. The most recent 100-200m have probably just got Office, a browser, Norton or some other security package, Skype and their favourite IM client. Apart from gamers, most people don't continually look for and download PC apps - although they're there occasionally if need strikes.

........

Most "cool new stuff" will be in the browser, just as it is with the PC. And maybe, just maybe after you've got used to it, you'll bother to find out if there's a 20%-better application. Once there are easy metaphors for multiple browser windows and tabs on mobile, and more ubiquitous support for multi-tasking, the idea of a "widget" becomes obsolete. They're just contrivances to get around small screen size, I think.

And the endgame?

The bottom line is that I'm wondering if the massed billions of phone users will really care about iPhone-style junk applications. Personalisation is all very well - but it's best done upfront, not on an ongoing basis. The hand of fashion could also start to dictate that people customise something else rather than phones.

A vision of 4 billion "modified" smartphones represents a dystopia of geekiness.

I must admit to having a lot of sympathy with this view, probably the kindest alternative view is to extrapolate the iPhone evolution, where an 80/20 (at best) is emerging - a small number of Apps are selling well (and these are the "$13,000 a month" stories), but a huge number are not.

Incidentally, in case you were wondering where the money really is, news today that the iPhone has a 60% gross margin.